Kubectl attach vs kubectl exec?

Question

by using kubectl exec -ti POD_NAME bash I am able to access the terminal inside the container and execute the command.

I can understand the usability and convenient of the above command. As K8s Operator I use exec regularly.

However, What is the use case of kubectl attach POD_NAME?

How can it be utilised? What is the real purpose of it? In what situation or circumstance it can be used?

Solution 1

The use cases for kubectl attach are discussed in kubernetes/issue 23335.

It can attach to the main process run by the container, which is not always bash.
As opposed to exec, which allows you to execute any process within the container (often: bash)

# Get output from running pod 123456-7890, using the first container by default
kubectl attach 123456-7890

# Get output from ruby-container from pod 123456-7890
kubectl attach 123456-7890 -c ruby-container

This article proposes:

In addition to interactive execution of commands, you can now also attach to any running process. Like kubectl logs, you’ll get stderr and stdout data, but with attach, you’ll also be able to send stdin from your terminal to the program.
Awesome for interactive debugging, or even just sending ctrl-c to a misbehaving application.

  $> kubectl attach redis -i

---

Again, the main difference is in the process you interact with in the container:

• exec: any one you want to create
• attach: the one currently running (no choice)

Solution 2

The kubectl attach command is similar to kubectl exec, but it attaches to the main process running in the container instead of running an additional one.

Comments

[Suresh Vishnoi]

Thanks for the answer. I was not aware of that It's possible to send stdin from terminal to misbehaving container process. Glad to know new things. Cheers

[shadow0359]

Ctrl-c will simply detach from the container. It will not send the signal to the process. How do we send the signal to the process?

[VonC]

@ns94 That is a good question: can you ask it as a separate question, with your OS and Kubernetes version?