ASP.NET/JavaScript - Why Isn't "Return False" Not Preventing Postback?
write return
statement so when you click on button it return false
which not allow to submit form
<asp:Button ID="btnFoo" runat="server" Text="Foo" CssClass="button foo"
OnClientClick="return foo_Click();" />
Related videos on Youtube
RPM1984
~ Past ~: Mainframes (Model 204, JCL) Java (J2SE, J2EE) Oracle VB.NET ASP.NET Web Forms/MVC ~ Present ~ .NET Core TDD, DDD (all the DDs!) Microservices Containers
Updated on April 29, 2022Comments
-
RPM1984 almost 2 years
I feel like i've done this scenario plenty of times, and it usually works, so im obviously missing something.
Here's my server-side ASP.NET Button:
<asp:Button ID="btnFoo" runat="server" Text="Foo" CssClass="button foo" OnClientClick="foo_Click();" />
Which get's rendered on the client as:
<input type="submit" name="reallylongclientid" value="Foo" onclick="foo_Click();WebForm_DoPostBackWithOptions(new WebForm_PostBackOptions(reallylongclientidandpostbackoptions, false, false))" id="reallylongclientid" class="button foo">
No surprises there.
Here's the surprise, in my JavaScript function:
function foo_Click() { return false; }
Okay so there's more to it than that, but i cut it down to prove a point.
When i click the button, it calls the client-side function, and returns false.
But it still posts back to the server, why?
I basically want to do this on the click of the button:
- Do client-side validation.
- If validation passes, post back
- If not, show some error messages on the form.
Of course, i could change this to an client-side button (input type="button") and manually kick off the postback when i want, but i shouldn't need to do that. Or should i?
-
RPM1984 over 13 yearsKnew it was obvious (slaps head). Thanks.
-
RPM1984 over 13 yearsI just noticed that if i do "var passedValidation = new Boolean(false); return passedValidation" it still posts back. But if i just do return false, it doesnt. WTF? any ideas?
-
Christian C. Salvadó over 13 years@RPM1984: Using the
Boolean
constructor, with thenew
keyword, creates aBoolean
object wrapper, and in JavaScript any object is considered to be truthy when used in boolean context, for example:!!new Boolean(false)
==>true
, I would recommend you to simply use the booleantrue
orfalse
literals, which represent directly primitive values... -
RPM1984 over 13 years@CMS - yep, i figured that. well that kinda sucks, oh well - ill stick to the basic. thanks for the clarification.