How to kill this threading.Timer?
The problem here can be solved by reading the documentation more carefully. A timer thread's cancel
method "... will only work if the timer is still in its waiting stage."
By the time you call t.cancel
the timer has fired, and its associated function is executing so it is no longer "in its waiting stage", even though the function actually spends most of its time sleeping - this does NOT mean it's in its waiting stage, which terminates when the timer fires..
More generally there is no way to kill a thread without its active cooperation, as several SO answers already summarize well.
Rather than using cancel
you should set some sort of flag that function
looks at to determine whether it should terminate its loop (and therefore the whole thread) or not.
Admin
Updated on June 04, 2022Comments
-
Admin almost 2 years
I have launched a thread using a
Timer
object. Now, I want to stop this thread but I can't. I have usedcancel()
, but it doesn't work. I don't know why.import threading import time import sys as system def Nop(): print("do nothing") return 0 def function(): try: while True: print("hello world ") time.sleep(2) except KeyboardInterrupt: print( "Good job!! exception catched") t = threading.Timer(10, function) t.start() print(t.getName) counter = 0 while True: try: time.sleep(1) Nop() counter = counter +1 print(counter) if counter == 20: print(t.getName) t.cancel() counter = 0 break if t.is_alive() == False: print("The Timer thread is dead...") except KeyboardInterrupt: print("End of program") t.cancel() system.exit(0) except: print("something wrong happens...") if t.is_alive() == True: print("timer is alive...") print(t.getName) t.cancel() print("final") system.exit(0)
The thread should stop when counter is equal to 20, but it is still alive. When I am out of the while loop, there is another check. The Timer is alive, is the same thread, I try to cancel, but it doesn't work.
Any Idea?
do nothing 17 hello world do nothing 18 do nothing 19 hello world do nothing 20 <bound method _Timer.getName of <_Timer(Thread-6, started daemon 9916)>> timer is alive... <bound method _Timer.getName of <_Timer(Thread-6, started daemon 9916)>> final To exit: use 'exit', 'quit', or Ctrl-D. An exception has occurred, use %tb to see the full traceback. SystemExit: 0 hello world hello world hello world hello world