Is it possible that X11 can be forwarded through a SSH tunnel
Solution 1
Yes, this is possible in a few different ways but you will need an X window server for Windows. Some options of a X windows server are XManager, XMing and MobaXterm. Once you have an X server running on Windows you can use PuTTY to connect to your host after you have set the configuration parameters:
Connection/SSH/X11
Enable X11 forwarding
X display location: localhost:10.0
Where the 10.0 depends on what the X Window server is listening on.
When you configured the X Window server and PuTTY and logged in to your host you can verify the DISPLAY
variable if a DISPLAY
is set:
$ echo $DISPLAY
localhost:10.0
Then try something like xclock
to see if X11 forwarding works:
# xclock &
Another way to use X11 apart from ssh
is to set the DISPLAY
variable manually to point to an IP address like:
# export DISPLAY=192.168.0.1:0
And see if it works:
# xclock &
This way X applications are (re)directed to output to a remote X Window server.
Note: Keep in mind that the X11 protocol is not designed to operate over slow network (WAN) connections. The X application may be terrible slow when used over slow connections. Consider to use the -C
(compression) switch with ssh
to use compression over the ssh
session to speed it up a little.
Solution 2
Hi if you want to use the putty like use Openssh with -x you have to install XMING on your windows machine . it became like some sort of server then you have to config you putty to forward X11 of you ssh connection over this server
Solution 3
Yet another solution is to install Cygwin on your Windows machine. It has both ssh
client and X11
server (be sure to install the corresponding packages).
Keep in mind that many X11
installations forbid untrusted X forwarding. Perhaps the simplest way around this is to use -Y
option in ssh
ssh -Y user@server
xclock
Related videos on Youtube
sleepy
Updated on September 18, 2022Comments
-
sleepy over 1 year
I communicate with the server via a ssh tunnel, configured via Putty.
Recently, I'm trying to forward the X11 through it, but it doesn't work.
Is there any one work this way?
Searched with google, but didn't find anything.
-
Naftuli Kay over 8 yearsWith regular OpenSSH, you should be able to pass the
-X
flag and X forward, but I'm not sure how that would be accomplished over a TCP port. -
Jonathan Ben-Avraham over 8 yearsIf you are using PuTTY does that mean that the host from which you are connecting to the server is running MS Windows? If so, then you would need an X server running on Windows that is configured to accept TCP connections.
-
Deb over 8 yearsYou wrote 'it doesn't work'. In future questions, please explain in what way it doesn't work: what you tried, what error messages you see, what relevant log messages, and what behavior you saw.
-
Ismael Miguel over 8 yearsIf you are using Debian, take a look at: superuser.com/a/862647/391087
-
-
rackandboneman over 8 yearsSmall wording issue there: What he needs is an X Window server. A window manager would usually be included in such an installation, but isn't 100% necessary, and could even be run on the remote machine.
-
rackandboneman over 8 yearsXMING is one good solution, but not the only one.
-
chrishollinworth almost 6 yearsJust like the terms "client" and "server", be careful of the terms "trusted" and "untrusted". A "trusted" connection is one where several of the usual security controls are disabled - i.e. you trust the system you are connecting to not to bad things to you.