Using FFMPEG to stream continuously videos files to a RTMP server

Question

ffmpeg handles RTMP streaming as input or output, and it's working well.

I want to stream some videos (a dynamic playlist managed by a python script) to a RTMP server, and i'm currently doing something quite simple: streaming my videos one by one with FFMPEG to the RTMP server, however this causes a connection break every time a video end, and the stream is ready to go when the next video begins.

I would like to stream those videos without any connection breaks continuously, then the stream could be correctly viewed.

I use this command to stream my videos one by one to the server

ffmpeg -re -y -i myvideo.mp4 -vcodec libx264 -b:v 600k -r 25 -s 640x360 \
-filter:v yadif -ab 64k -ac 1 -ar 44100 -f flv \
"rtmp://mystreamingserver/app/streamName"

I looked for some workarounds over the internet for many days, and i found some people talking about using a named pipe as input in ffmpeg, I've tried it and it didn't work well since ffmpeg does not only close the RTMP stream when a new video comes but also closes itself.

Is there any way to do this ? (stream a dynamic playlist of videos with ffmpeg to RTMP server without connection breaks

Solution 1

Update (as I can't delete the accepted answer): the proper solution is to implement a custom demuxer, similar to the concat one. There's currently no other clean way. You have to get your hands dirty and code!

Below is an ugly hack. This is a very bad way to do it, just don't!

The solution uses the concat demuxer and assumes all your source media files use the same codec. The example is based on MPEG-TS but the same can be done for RTMP.

1. Make a playlist file holding a huge list of entry points for you dynamic playlist with the following format:

   file 'item_1.ts' file 'item_2.ts' file 'item_3.ts' [...] file 'item_[ENOUGH_FOR_A_LIFETIME].ts'

   These files are just placeholders.

2. Make a script that keeps track of you current playlist index and creates symbolic links on-the-fly for current_index + 1

   ln -s /path/to/what/to/play/next.ts item_1.ts

   ln -s /path/to/what/to/play/next.ts item_2.ts

   ln -s /path/to/what/to/play/next.ts item_3.ts

   [...]

3. Start playing ffmpeg -f concat -i playlist.txt -c copy output -f mpegts udp://<ip>:<port>

4. Get chased and called names by an angry system administrator

Solution 2

Need to create two playlist files and at the end of each file specify a link to another file.

list_1.txt

ffconcat version 1.0
file 'item_1.mp4'
file 'list_2.txt'

list_2.txt

ffconcat version 1.0
file 'item_2.mp4'
file 'list_1.txt'

Now all you need is to dynamically change the contents of the next playlist file.

Solution 3

You can pipe your loop to a buffer, and from this buffer you pipe to your streaming instance.

In shell it would look like:

#!/bin/bash

for i in *.mp4; do
        ffmpeg -hide_banner -nostats -i "$i" -c:v mpeg2video \
[proper settings] -f mpegts -
done | mbuffer -q -c -m 20000k | ffmpeg -hide_banner \ 
-nostats -re -fflags +igndts \ 
-thread_queue_size 512 -i pipe:0 -fflags +genpts \ 
[proper codec setting] -f flv rtmp://127.0.0.1/live/stream

Of course you can use any kind of loop, also looping through a playlist.

• I figure out that mpeg is a bit more stabile, then x264 for the input stream.
• I don't know why, but minimum 2 threads for the mpeg compression works better.
• the input compression need to be faster then the output frame rate, so we get fast enough new input.
• Because of the non-continuing timestamp we have to skip them and generate a new one in the output.
• The buffer size needs to be big enough for the loop to have enough time to get the new clip.

I work on python based solution, is not complete yet, but except some warnings my test stream runs multiple days:

ffplayout

This uses a xml playlist format. And the Playlist is dynamic, in that way that you can edit always the current playlist, and change tracks or add new ones.

Solution 4

Very Late Answer, but I recently ran into the exact same issue as the poster above.

I solved this problem by using OBS and the OBS websockets plugin.

First, set your RTMP streaming app as you have it now. but stream to a LOCAL RTMP stream.

Then have OBS load this RTMP stream as a VLC source layer with the local RTMP as the source.

then (in your app), using the OBS websockets plugin, have your VLC source switch to a static black video or PNG file when the video ends. Then switch back to the RTMP stream once the next video starts. This will prevent the RTMP stream from stopping when the video ends. OBS will go black durring the short transition, but the final OBS RTMP output will never stop.

There is surely a way to do this with manually setting up a intermediate RTMP server that pushes to a final RTMP server, but I find using OBS to be easier, with little overhead.

I hope this helps others, this solutions has been working incredible for me.

View more solutions

Comments

[kketch]

thanks, just saw your answer. I figured it out with hinekyle comment earlier, even if I am not interested in these kind of hacks now

[chovy]

Can you elaborate on what you mean by Make a script that keeps track of you current playlist index and creates symbolic links on-the-fly for current_index + 1? What purpose is this for?

[chovy]

Trying to do same thing for .m3u8 24/7 stream. But the command -c copy output -f mpegts stream.m3u8 throws an error.

[aergistal]

@chovy this is a very bad answer on my part which I posted more like a joke. Really, don't do it like this, it's an ugly hack. I'll delete it so nobody else gets tempted to try it.

[josh]

The shell command that you have provided does not work as expected. A temporary buffer stored inside mbuffer is playing. The temporary buffer keeps looping.how to flush the buffer? I tried adding a pipe too with not much success. Any ideas?

[chovy]

How do I execute with ffmpeg?