What are the advantages of using an ExecutorService?

Question

What is the advantage of using ExecutorService over running threads passing a Runnable into the Thread constructor?

Solution 1

ExecutorService abstracts away many of the complexities associated with the lower-level abstractions like raw Thread. It provides mechanisms for safely starting, closing down, submitting, executing, and blocking on the successful or abrupt termination of tasks (expressed as Runnable or Callable).

From JCiP, Section 6.2, straight from the horse's mouth:

Executor may be a simple interface, but it forms the basis for a flexible and powerful framework for asynchronous task execution that supports a wide variety of task execution policies. It provides a standard means of decoupling task submission from task execution, describing tasks as Runnable. The Executor implementations also provide lifecycle support and hooks for adding statistics gathering, application management, and monitoring. ... Using an Executor is usually the easiest path to implementing a producer-consumer design in your application.

Rather than spending your time implementing (often incorrectly, and with great effort) the underlying infrastructure for parallelism, the j.u.concurrent framework allows you to instead focus on structuring tasks, dependencies, potential parallelism. For a large swath of concurrent applications, it is straightforward to identify and exploit task boundaries and make use of j.u.c, allowing you to focus on the much smaller subset of true concurrency challenges which may require more specialized solutions.

Also, despite the boilerplate look and feel, the Oracle API page summarizing the concurrency utilities includes some really solid arguments for using them, not least:

Developers are likely to already understand the standard library classes, so there is no need to learn the API and behavior of ad-hoc concurrent components. Additionally, concurrent applications are far simpler to debug when they are built on reliable, well-tested components.

This question on SO asks about a good book, to which the immediate answer is JCiP. If you haven't already, get yourself a copy. The comprehensive approach to concurrency presented there goes well beyond this question, and will save you a lot of heartache in the long run.

Solution 2

An advantage I see is in managing/scheduling several threads. With ExecutorService, you don't have to write your own thread manager which can be plagued with bugs. This is especially useful if your program needs to run several threads at once. For example you want to execute two threads at a time, you can easily do it like this:

ExecutorService exec = Executors.newFixedThreadPool(2);

exec.execute(new Runnable() {
  public void run() {
    System.out.println("Hello world");
  }
});

exec.shutdown();

The example may be trivial, but try to think that the "hello world" line consists of a heavy operation and you want that operation to run in several threads at a time in order to improve your program's performance. This is just one example, there are still many cases that you want to schedule or run several threads and use ExecutorService as your thread manager.

For running a single thread, I don't see any clear advantage of using ExecutorService.

Solution 3

The following limitations from traditional Thread overcome by Executor framework(built-in Thread Pool framework).

• Poor Resource Management i.e. It keep on creating new resource for every request. No limit to creating resource. Using Executor framework we can reuse the existing resources and put limit on creating resources.
• Not Robust : If we keep on creating new thread we will get StackOverflowException exception consequently our JVM will crash.
• Overhead Creation of time : For each request we need to create new resource. To creating new resource is time consuming. i.e. Thread Creating > task. Using Executor framework we can get built in Thread Pool.

Benefits of Thread Pool

• Use of Thread Pool reduces response time by avoiding thread creation during request or task processing.

• Use of Thread Pool allows you to change your execution policy as you need. you can go from single thread to multiple thread by just replacing ExecutorService implementation.

• Thread Pool in Java application increases stability of system by creating a configured number of threads decided based on system load and available resource.

• Thread Pool frees application developer from thread management stuff and allows to focus on business logic.

Source

Solution 4

Below are some benefits:

1. Executor service manage thread in asynchronous way
2. Use Future callable to get the return result after thread completion.
3. Manage allocation of work to free thread and resale completed work from thread for assigning new work automatically
4. fork - join framework for parallel processing
5. Better communication between threads
6. invokeAll and invokeAny give more control to run any or all thread at once
7. shutdown provide capability for completion of all thread assigned work
8. Scheduled Executor Services provide methods for producing repeating invocations of runnables and callables Hope it will help you

Solution 5

ExecutorService also gives access to FutureTask which will return to the calling class the results of a background task once completed. In the case of implementing Callable

public class TaskOne implements Callable<String> {

@Override
public String call() throws Exception {
    String message = "Task One here. . .";
    return message;
    }
}

public class TaskTwo implements Callable<String> {

@Override
public String call() throws Exception {
    String message = "Task Two here . . . ";
    return message;
    }
}

// from the calling class

ExecutorService service = Executors.newFixedThreadPool(2);
    // set of Callable types
    Set<Callable<String>>callables = new HashSet<Callable<String>>();
    // add tasks to Set
    callables.add(new TaskOne());
    callables.add(new TaskTwo());
    // list of Future<String> types stores the result of invokeAll()
    List<Future<String>>futures = service.invokeAll(callables);
    // iterate through the list and print results from get();
    for(Future<String>future : futures) {
        System.out.println(future.get());
    }

View more solutions