What is the difference between Popup , chromeless window, modal-window, lightbox, hover ad?
Solution 1
Popup: Anything that pops up from your browser. They tend to annoy users, and therefore they are often blocked by the browsers.
Chromeless Window: Just another kind of popup window that doesn't show the browser menu or toolbar.
Modal Window: The JavaScript alert()
method is an example of a modal dialog. The users must acknowledge the popup before they can return to operate the parent application.
Lightbox: A modal-dialog JavaScript implementation normally used to display images. Requires JavaScipt and it isn't blocked by browsers unless JavaScript has been disabled.
Hover Ad: These are implemented in JavaScript similarly to Lightbox, but are not modal so the users may continue using the parent application. They are used for online advertising solutions and most implementations do not scroll with the web page, and therefore may obscure some of the content. While there is a big chance that Hover Ads may annoy users, they are quite difficult to block.
Solution 2
Depending on the Browser you use, Internet Explorer and Firefox completely blocks the pop-ups with JavaScript Disabled, Google Chrome on the other hand lets Alert Boxes and Announcement boxes still pop-up.You can test it here using your Google Chrome Browser: Alert Box
Jitendra Vyas
Hi, I am Jitendra a front-end developer from India specializing in web standards, accessibility, and usability based development.
Updated on June 04, 2022Comments
-
Jitendra Vyas almost 2 years
What is the difference between Popup , chromeless window, modal-window, lightbox, hover ad?
Which is unblockable with default setting on any browser, more accessible with screen reader and even accessible if javascript disabled?
-
Jitendra Vyas about 14 yearsaccessify.com/tools-and-wizards/accessibility-tools/… this tool three type of popup . What is the difference between these three
-
Jitendra Vyas about 14 yearsand among all these as i asked in my question which method's content can be accessible even if javascript is disabled?
-
Daniel Vassallo about 14 years@Jitendra: Most probably only the traditional popup would work with JavaScript disabled. However that is the one which is mostly blocked by browsers.
-
Boris Guéry about 14 yearsPopup are opened trhough javascript, it's a 'new browser window' without some toolbars. Aren't they ? Well, the most efficient way to be accessible, without annoy users should be to use (target=_blank or not, but use a specific class), to open 'popup like', and to parse it with javascript to open it as lightbox if javascript is enabled.
-
Daniel Vassallo about 14 yearsI think the
target=_blank
links can be classified as popups as well.