WPF Textblock TargetNullValue not working?

Question

I have a wpf textblock as below:

<TextBlock Text="{Binding [someViewModel].SomeVar.SomeSubVar.Name, 
                          TargetNullValue='-'}"/>

At my viewmodel side, I'll have my own logic that in the end, SomeVar.SomeSubVar will be null.

If I want to show a default value for this TextBlock I know I can declare and initiate SomeVar.SomeSubVar and assign default value into SomeVar.SomeSubVar.Name but I would like to use TargetNullValue instead. May I know which part is wrong?

Solution 1

You might look at using FallbackValue http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/system.windows.data.bindingbase.fallbackvalue(v=vs.110).aspx in conjunction with TargetNullValue.

In order for TargetNullValue to work you must be able to evaluate the full path of [someViewModel].SomeVar.SomeSubVar.Name to null. If 'someViewModel', 'SomeVar', or 'SomeSubVar' are null then 'Name' can never be evaluated, and TargetNullValue won't apply.

Solution 2

The Binding's TargetNullValue property is displayed in the TextBlock if the [somveViewModel].SomeVar.SomeSubVar.Name property is null. It doesn't cane the value of the [somveViewModel].SomeVar.SomeSubVar.Name property. It effectively sets up an equivalency between null and the TargetNullValue property's value.

See this question for a good explanation.

So my advice is if you want to have a non-null default value, you need to set it in the view model.

Comments

[Tim Pohlmann]

This is what appears to happen, however this is not explained at all in the linked question. In fact, there are a lot of confusing answers and comments posted on that question.

[Tim Pohlmann]

I made a new question regarding TargetNullValue: stackoverflow.com/questions/36402291/…