Can't ping broadcast

Question

We're running four computers connected to a hub (yes a hub not a switch) on Fedora 13. They were installed using images from a colleague that has recently left us to go back to school, they may have been set to somehow block the use of the broadcast, but we'd like to continue using this image. We've setup the static IPs for each computer using ifconfig (we've also tried ip addr add) to 10.0.1.11/24 through 10.0.1.14/24, using these settings we can't seem to ping the broadcast which is indeed set correctly to 10.0.1.255, using tcpdump we see nothing except outgoing ping requests from the computer that calls the ping request. Does anyone have any ideas or am I missing something entirely?

Solution 1

echo 0 >/proc/sys/net/ipv4/icmp_echo_ignore_broadcasts - as root.

You may need to also use the -b option with ping and it will most likely require root permissions.

Solution 2

Broadcast amplification was used to mount DOS (Denial of Service) attacks. As a result most IP stacks now turn off echo responses to broadcast ping. This is normal behavior now.

Comments

[Admin]

Are you using ping -b?

[Jon Phenow]

That's sort of what we were figuring, I guess I wasn't sure it was default but it would make sense... does anyone use broadcast messages anymore?

[Jon Phenow]

Very nice, not sure how I would've found that

[LawrenceC]

Broadcast is so 1995. Multicast is what the cool kids are doing now.

[Shawn J. Goff]

@jphenow - you find it like so: man ping Once inside the man program, do /broadcast. It jumps right to the relevant part.

[Jon Phenow]

Oh I knew about the -b part, it was the option that needed changing, I use manuals quite often.

[Jon Phenow]

Haha yea our Network professor figured he'd dig way back into the ages of Networking.

[peterh]

@LawrenceC Not 95, around 99 as I can remember (smurf)