How to run a command in background with no output unless there's an error

Question

How to suppress a command's output but show it if the command exit codes an error?

Solution 1

Unfortunately, the assumption that stderr is only used for error output isn't always correct. Rather, stderr is often used for any and all interactive output and diagnostics, i.e. output intended for the user to read in an interactive prompt¹. wget and dd are well-known examples.

Some commands will provide a flag (e.g. -quiet or -silent) to suppress non-error output - read their man pages to see if one exists.

---

Another convention that holds more often is the exit code: a program returns an exit code when it exits. Typically², an exit code of 0 indicates success, and any other exit code indicates an error.

With bash, you can get the exit code of the last command from the $? variable. In fish, use the $status variable. You can pipe stderr to a temporary file and only print it if an error occurs. For example (fish):

command 2>/tmp/outputbuffer
if $status
    cat /tmp/outputbuffer
rm /tmp/outputbuffer

You can also use some shortcuts, if you aren't chaining commands:

if command 2>/tmp/outputbuffer
    cat /tmp/outputbuffer
rm /tmp/outputbuffer

Or:

command 2>/tmp/outputbuffer; or cat /tmp/outputbuffer; rm /tmp/outputbuffer;

You can also pipe stdout to the same buffer by using 2>&1 >/tmp/outputbuffer.

(Note: I don't actually know fish, so I'm adapting the concept to what I can find in its documentation. The syntax might be slightly wrong. Also, you can use mktemp to generate a unique temporary file - run it and record the filename in a variable.)

If you need to run the whole thing in the background of a shell you are also using interactively at the same time, then you're better off writing a script to handle the output-hiding and running that script in the background with the standard techniques (fish). Heck, you can put something like the following function in ~/.config/fish/config.fish:

function run-silent
    set temp (mktemp)
    if $argv 2>&1 >$temp
        cat $temp
    rm $temp
end

Call with run-silent somecommand & (where the trailing & causes it to run in the background)

Note that this will swallow the original exit code, and will dump both stdout and stderr in the event of a failure. You can customise it as necessary.

---

¹ There isn't even a guarantee that error output won't appear on stdout - some programs will dump all output there!

² Unfortunately, this still isn't always the case - the exit code is completely controlled by the program, and some will indicate some success conditions with non-zero exits. Again, check the manual.

Solution 2

Unix utilities send general messages to stdout, and error messages to stderr, so if we only want to see error messages, then it will be sufficient to suppress stdout so only stderr gets output to the console.

The way to do this (in both bash and fish) is to append >/dev/null to the command. This pipes stdout into nothingness, but stderr (with your error messages) still comes through to the console.

So for instance:

The command echo 1 >/dev/null prints nothing, because the normal stdout output is suppressed, and nothing was written to stderr.

The command man doesnotexist >/dev/null prints an error message, because man writes its error message to stderr.

Solution 3

This will run the command in the background and write errors to a log file whilest ignoring normal output

    command > /dev/null 2> /tmp/example_error.log &

Comments

[Xster]

slight fish tweak, there's a special place for putting functions in ~/.config/fish/functions/