How to tell gzip to keep original file?

Question

I would like to compress a text file using gzip command line tool while keeping the original file. By default running the following command

gzip file.txt

results in modifying this file and renaming it file.txt.gz. instead of this behavior I would like to have this new compressed file in addition to the existing one file.txt. For now I am using the following command to do that

gzip -c file.txt > file.txt.gz

It works but I am wondering why there is no easier solution to do such a common task ? Maybe I missed the option doing that ?

Solution 1

For GNU gzip 1.6 or above, FreeBSD and derivatives or recent versions of NetBSD, see don_cristi's answer.

With any version, you can use shell redirections as in:

gzip < file.txt > file.txt.gz

When not given any argument, gzip reads its standard input, compresses it and writes the compressed version to its standard output. As a bonus, when using shell redirections, you don't have to worry about files called "--help" or "-" (that latter one still being a problem for gzip -c --).

Another benefit over gzip -c file.txt > file.txt.gz is that if file.txt can't be opened, the command will fail without creating an empty file.txt.gz (or overwriting an existing file.txt.gz) and without running gzip at all.

A significant difference compared to gzip -k though is that there will be no attempt at copying the file.txt's metadata (ownership, permissions, modification time, name of uncompressed file) to file.txt.gz.

Also if file.txt.gz already existed, it will silently override it unless you have turned the noclobber option on in your shell (with set -o noclobber for instance in POSIX shells).

Solution 2

Note that the recently (June 2013) released gzip-1.6 "accepts the --keep (-k) option, for consistency with tools like xz, lzip and bzip2. With this option, gzip no longer removes named input files when compressing or decompressing".

Excerpt from the man page:

  -k --keep
         Keep (don't delete) input files during compression or decompression.

So, as of 1.6, you can use -k or --keep to keep the original file:

gzip -k -- "$file"

(note that it doesn't work if $file is - (which gzip interprets as meaning stdin instead of the actual file called -), in which case, you have to change it to ./-)

That option was first introduced in the FreeBSD implementation of gzip (in FreeBSD 7.0 in 2007) for consistency with bzip2. That gzip is based on a rewrite of GNU gzip by NetBSD. The -k option eventually made it back to NetBSD in 2010.

Solution 3

From the documentation it seems that there is no option to create a copy of the file.

You can define a shell function

gzipkeep() {
    if [ -f "$1" ] ; then
        gzip -c -- "$1" > "$1.gz"
    fi
}

and then

gzipkeep file.txt

Comments

[SHW]

This is because, gzip compresses the given file and creates new file. Compression means squeezing original file and replacing it with new one. Your "-c" option is explicitly telling gzip to save it with other name. That's why it works

[Manuel Selva]

@SHW I didn't get your comment ... ?

[daisy]

@ManuelSelva once the original file is compressed, it's no longer needed, I guess that was the design.

[Mateen Ulhaq]

Why gzip/gunzip do this by default when no other unix tool does this is beyond me.

[codewaggle]

Now this addresses the specifics of the OP's question and answers the general question "How to tell gzip to keep the original file". Very handy and more useful than -c.

[user3174706]

Geez. RHEL6 only comes with zip 1.3.12 in base...

[Stéphane Chazelas]

Note that if the file is -, you have to call it as gzipkeep ./-.

[paul]

This works on Mac/OS X :) (which is BSD)

[MichaelChirico]

Are there many standard distros not using >= 1.6 anymore? Wondering if answer needs updat

[flow2k]

What's the -k option? Couldn't find it in the man pages, e.g. this version here linux.die.net/man/1/gzip. Also, it looks like gzip copies the file's metadata by default.

[flow2k]

ah, I see it on my macos but too bad it's not on RHEL nor Ubuntu. Thanks.

[notilas]

What is "--" for? I think gzip -k "file" works fine.

[don_crissti]

@notilas see unix.stackexchange.com/q/11376/22142

[killjoy]

This was ideal for me, and allowed me to one-line my program logic. gunzip < $log | grep foo | gzip > foo-$log.gz

[Sathya]

@MichaelChirico CentOS 7. :(

[GypsyCosmonaut]

@StéphaneChazelas Working on gzip version 1.4 as well. cat file | gzip > file.gz

[Fonic]

This is the best solution for scripts IMO, as you can be sure the output file > "$1.gz" will exist exactly like specified. Furthermore, you can also specify a different name if the need should arise.

[Isin Altinkaya]

It can be put to .bashrc as a small function gzik(){gzip < ${1} > ${1}.gz}

[Admin]

@IsinAltinkaya, gzik(){gzip < ${1} > ${1}.gz} is zsh syntax. In bash, you need gzik() { gzip < "$1" > "$1".gz; }