IsDate Function in SQL evaluates invalid dates as valid

Question

I am running a SQL Statement against imported data from Excel Files. In this SQL I am checking if the users have entered dates properly by using IsDate function. Since this is a raw data that hasn't been converted yet, all dates are stored in a varchar data type field.

In some circumstances IsDate returns 1 (valid date) when there is clearly an incorrect date format entered by the user.

For Example:

07/001/2012

2012-07-002

007/002/2012

Any Suggestions on how to handle this problem?

SELECT *
  FROM tblImport
 WHERE (ISDATE(dt) = 0 
        AND (dt is not null AND dt <> ''))

Thanks!

p.s. Smacking users' did not help.

Solution 1

I do a lot of data conversion work and here is a function that I created and use it practically everyday to weed out the bad dates:

CREATE FUNCTION dbo.fnCheckDate
(@InDate nvarchar(50))
RETURNS DATETIME
AS
    BEGIN
        declare @Return DATETIME

        select @return = CASE WHEN ISDATE(@InDate) = 1
                            THEN CASE WHEN CAST(@InDate as DATETIME) BETWEEN '1/1/1901 12:00:00 AM' AND '6/6/2079 12:00:00 AM'
                                    THEN @InDate
                                    ELSE null
                                    END
                            ELSE null
                            END
        return @return
    END
GO

Results:

SELECT dbo.fnCheckDate('07/001/2012') --> Returns 2012-07-01 00:00:00.000
SELECT dbo.fnCheckDate('2012-07-002') --> Returns 2012-07-01 00:00:00.000
SELECT dbo.fnCheckDate('007/002/2012') --> Returns 2012-07-01 00:00:00.000
SELECT dbo.fnCheckDate('00/002/2012') --> Returns Null
SELECT dbo.fnCheckDate('006/031/2012') --> Returns Null
SELECT dbo.fnCheckDate('') --> Returns Null

Solution 2

Try setting the dateformat first - that worked for me when I was seeing exceptions.

set dateformat dmy
select IsDate(<column>)
from Table

Solution 3

maybe just check dt's LEN? however, it can not handle cases when the len is valid. maybe input validation should happen in the frontend?