Starter theme for Drupal 7? Stark? Zen?

Question

I have been using Drupal 6 for a year and always used Zen Sub-Theme for every project. So, should I keep using Zen for Drupal 7? Or is Drupal 7 bringing a better alternative? Maybe the Stark theme?

Solution 1

I am a long time Zen user myself and I have also used Zen for a Drupal 7 project recently. Although I have some doubts about the number of style sheets, I still found it very easy and familiar to work with.

I think you cannot compare Zen to Stark, because Stark is not really meant as a starter theme, but rather a theme (or should we call it a non-theme?) that shows what Drupal looks like without theming. There are other starter themes you could consider, like Fusion and Genesis for instance. Check out the Starter Themes page for more info.

Solution 2

It's also worth mentioning Tao for the record - as the name suggests it was a new take on the Zen idea, very popular for a while.

It's a good, solid, straightforward, non-nonsense base theme that doesn't get in the way. It's also got some useful themes built on top of it, particularly the excellent admin theme Rubik). Here's a good article comparing Tao to Zen (drupal 6 angle, but the comments bring it up to date and the general idea is relevant to Drupal 7).

You should be aware however that at time of writing its sponsor company appears to have ceased development as they move away from Drupal and that documentation was never anything like as good as Zen had.

---

Finally, regardless of base theme, for anyone interested in keeping stylesheets sane and manageable, it's worth checking out the LESS CSS preprocessor module - here's a great article explaining what it does.

Solution 3

You might wint to try out the Zentropy starter theme. Great for starting a template, well maintained and cutting edge.

From the Zentropy Drupal page:

Zentropy is a base theme which attempts to bring the best of a couple worlds together:

It converts the core template files to HTML5 markup (based on Boron - all credit to Scott Vandehey (spaceninja) of Metal Toad Media)

It adds useful features from the classic Basic theme

It includes an HTML5-friendly CSS Reset & other best practices from Paul Irish's HTML5 Boilerplate

It also features a bunch of other goodies thrown in: more regions, Google Analytics integration, support for Modernizr (http://www.modernizr.com/) and all sorts of awesomeness

Solution 4

After some research and tests I decided to build my own base theme starting from Stark up. Just follow the online documentation and keep it as flexible as possible, I'd suggest.

You can always add your own template.php and or .tpl.php files when needed.

Solution 5

Have you considered a grid system? http://drupal.org/project/omega is a particularly nice reworking of the 960gs theme.

View more solutions

Comments

[designer-trying-coding]

I was already considering to continue with Zen, but wasn't sure if I'm missing any other new good option for Drupal 7. I found Zen more reliable considering for future support. So I already have started with Zen :)

[designer-trying-coding]

This was what I was considering to use. I was just not sure with the future support. I think still Zen will be the first choice for Drupal 7... Thanks anyway for your link.