Flash drive doesn't mount on mac

Question

I've got two different USB flash drives which are formatted MS-DOS(FAT-16). When I plug each into my MacBook Pro (running MacOS 10.6 - Snow Leopard), they don't mount. I can see them using Disk Utility. When I run an Ubuntu VM inside of VMWare Fusion, Ubuntu has no trouble mounting these either.

I've tested with the drives plugged directly into the machine and plugged into a usb hub -- both give the same results.

Is there a setting I've inadvertently set which disables automounting? Is there an issue with mounting FAT-16 drives?

Solution

How large is the drive/partition? FAT16 can go as high as 4GB, but (according to Wikipedia) is "not widely supported". XP supports it, but earlier versions of Windows do not: they use the more conservative 2GB limit. Perhaps Mac OS X is also 2GB. (Not a surprise that Linux might support 4GB.) For more than 2GB, use FAT32.

I happen to have a 128MB stick with FAT16, and it mounted fine with Leopard (don't have Snow handy here).

In Disk Utility, what happens if you manually try to Mount the partition; or is it disabled?

Comments

[Doug Harris]

Interesting idea. One drive is 1GB, the other is 2GB. Manually mounting is enabled, but it fails and suggests running First Aid. I ran verify and repair but got the same results when I tried to mount.

[Doug Harris]

The previous comment was for the 2GB drive. The 1GB drive mounted after First Aid.

[Doug Harris]

I reformatted the 2GB drive using Disk Utility as "MS-DOS (FAT)" and it mounts fine. It now reports being formatted as FAT-32.