What determines the speed of an internet connection?

Question

I was using Speedtest.net to test my internet speeds, and was getting pretty good results (I think) (~2Mbits/s). Then Speedtest.net prompted me to go to their (affiliated?) website Pingtest.net, claiming that "Bandwidth tells only part of the story - test quality as well." My connection is not very fast. Speedtest.net told me I had ~2mbits/s download, but the Pingtest.net gave my connection an "F*".

Thus, my question is: What determines the speed of an internet connection? Bandwidth? What is "quality"?

Solution 1

Also, you have to consider that these tests are not very accurate all of the time. If you're using speedtest to measure your internet speeds, then you will also have to consider that the server that you're using to test with could be taking a huge hit. I've seen cases where I was getting only 10mbps on a speedtest server, but then changed to another server and was getting my subscribed 30mbps. I would first find out from your ISP what you're paying for. They should be able to provide you both your Download and Upload speeds. If you go to speedtest and you find that you're not getting anywhere near that then you will want to try a different speedtest server (one of the options before and after running a test). If you constantly find yourself not reaching your subscribed maxes then you will need to consider that you could potentially have an issue with your line. SNR (Signal Noise Ratio) can cause poor internet speeds and/or spontaneous intermittent connections. Your ISP may also be cheating you by throttling down your speed or you just have a plain weak signal. Some technologies like DSL will vary based on your geographical location in reference to the DSL provider. Technically you could reach the max speed, but unfortunately you live out in the sticks. Cable providers are more on a shared bandwidth. Even though you're given the allotment of bandwidth speeds, it may vary based on those around you with the same ISP. If you have 100 neighbors all on cable and slamming the servers, you may notice a hit. To give you a standard (very very loose):

Typical DSL -> 1.5mbps to 6mbps

Typical Cable -> 10mbps to 20mbps

Faster Cable -> 20mbps to 50mbps

Solution 2

Basically, it all comes to three things:

1. Bandwidth: How many bytes you can pass in 1 second (measured in bits per second).
2. Latency: How long does it take for a packet to reach its destination (measured in milliseconds, ms).
3. Packet loss: How many packets are lost along the route (measured in percents).

You want to increase #1 and decrease #2 and #3. Quality is combination of the three of these.

Comments

[Moab]

The Internet Gods of course ;->

[MaQleod]

DSL and cable are both shared, it is just done slightly differently - in both cases though, the DSLAM and the CMTS are still limited by the trunk that feeds them. They are both fed by ATMs that have set trunk speeds and all connections through them are limited in total to that speed (usually an OC3 (155mbps) or DS3 (45mbs), though can be more or have multiple trunks).

[kobaltz]

I'm at 50mbps right now with my home internet.