Are there downsides to Windows 8 Hybrid Shutdown?

Question

Are there any downside to Windows 8 not doing a "full" shutdown? Would it be good practice to occasionally do a full shutdown to do a full system initialization at boot?

If I'm already booting from SSD is there still a point to using Fast Startup?

Solution 1

A Full Boot differs from a Fast Boot in terms of services and driver loading. Both of them are saved into a hiberfile when shutdown and just resumed when Fast Booted. I can olny see the needing of a Full Boot if you noticed radical changes in drivers(a driver update for example) or the installation of a lot of new Windows Services.

Fortunatelly even when installing new services or new drivers Windows 8 will know about that and will automatically load the new one if it "misses" the hit of a hyberfile open try, so, in a few words, it's kind of subjective, but I don't think it is necessarily to make Full Reboots of your system unless you think you need for some specific reason such as driver update or even due to performance issues.

Solution 2

In addition to what Diogo and Root already said, you also should perform a full shutdown if you have another OS installed or if you plan to boot from an optical disc or a flash drive.

Any change made to the partitions visible to Windows while it is hibernating can result in data corruption. The hybrid shutdown was initially called Logoff + Hibernate, so suppose this still applies. Better safe than sorry...

Solution 3

Even with a SSD booting is not instantaneous. That's because there's CPU work involved to load the kernel, waiting time to detect and initialize hardware, verify configurations, etc. If it was just about the disk, windows would do a full load in about two seconds.

To your question as to whether "it would be good practice to occasionally do a full shutdown", I would like to point that doing a restart always does a full shutdown so unless you never use Restart you may be doing that already.

Also note that disabling Hibernate, a common "tip" for Windows 7 to save SSD disk space, also disables hybrid shutdown/fast boot.

Solution 4

Doing a hybrid shutdown has the following disadvantages:

• You cannot use wake on lan feature on some network cards.

• You cannot install new Windows updates if you do a hybrid shutdown using the command shutdown -s -hybrid

• Some drivers may only work if you do a full shutdown.

Even if you are using a SSD, hybrid boot will make the boot process way more faster than a cold boot.

Solution 5

Some report that you cannot enter the bios when powering up after a hybrid shutdown.

Read this article for full disclosure on hybrid boot

• Of course, there are times where you may want to perform a complete shutdown – for example, if you’re opening the system to add or change some hardware

There is one glaring error in that article where is speaks of using the shutdown switch "full" which no longer exists in W8 RTM

View more solutions

Comments

[Diogo]

You cannot install new Windows updates? Why not?

[Elmo]

If you download windows updates, they don't get installed until you do a full shutdown. Windows will automatically do a full shutdown if updates are ready to be installed but if you use the command 'shutdown -s -hybrid', which does a hybrid shutdown, they wont get installed.

[Midhun]

I use WOL quite a bit and have not run into any issues. I did initially but just had to update the driver for my Network Card.

[Elmo]

But it doesn't work for me. Maybe it is incompatible with my network card.

[Pacerier]

So if there's no downsides to fast shutdown (which is basically hibernation), does that mean that there are also no downsides to actual hibernation?

[Pacerier]

@VianEsterhuizen, See superuser.com/q/39532/78897

[Pacerier]

@Zuck, Regarding "Some drivers may only work if you do a full shutdown", I've not actually met even one. What are some examples?

[Moab]

Nice article here explains the different boot types

[patryk.beza]

I've been struggling with mounting Windows' partition in read-write mode on Linux and I ended up with disabling hybrid shutdown eventually.